Effortlessly Productive

Perfectionism Isn’t High Standards — It’s Self-Protection in Disguise

Annie Veblen McCarty

Perfectionism nearly destroyed me. Not the cute, Pinterest-worthy kind where you like your desk organized just so, but the exhausting, life-limiting shield that convinced me my worth depended on flawlessness.

Sobbing uncontrollably over a B grade that still tied me for first place? Or staying up until 3 AM on Christmas Eve ensuring every gift was wrapped with military precision? That was me. When I launched my business, perfectionism morphed into endless website tweaks, pixel adjustments, and offer revisions—all clever disguises for what was really happening: I was terrified to launch because launching meant the possibility of disappointing someone.

As Brené Brown wisely notes, perfectionism isn't about high standards—it's about avoiding blame, judgment, and shame. It's a shield we carry, believing it protects us when actually it prevents our flight. The breakthrough came when I finally understood that perfectionism is about self-protection while excellence is about service to others. Perfectionism demands flawlessness before showing up; excellence encourages showing up fully while continuing to grow.

Breaking free required intentionally doing things imperfectly, widening my tolerance for being seen when not polished, and building a business that could function despite my perfectionistic tendencies. This journey inspired the System Seer playbook—combining nervous system regulation with strategic business systems so you can create from a place of ease, flow, and self-trust.

Ready to stop letting perfectionism keep you safe but small? Visit my website

https://thesystemseer.com/ssplaybook

 or DM me "playbook" on Instagram @thesystemseer. The real magic happens when you show up before you feel ready—not perfect, not polished, just present.

Coaches, healers, and creatives—how much money are you leaving on the table?

Coach OS is the world’s leading all-in-one software that automates your business, scales your income, and replaces all your other software for a fraction of the cost!

Grab your free trial now, at https://coachossoftware.com/

Speaker 0:

Hey friend, welcome back. Today I want to talk about perfectionism, not the cute Pinterest-y kind where you like things a certain way. I'm talking about the deep, exhausting, self-protective perfectionism that quietly runs your life until you don't even remember who you are without it. And I want to tell you my story. Senior year of high school I was that kid Straight A's always first in my class. Valedictorian was basically already printed on my forehead. And then I got my first B. I remember sitting in the guidance counselor's office and just breaking. I sobbed uncontrollably for an hour, couldn't breathe, couldn't talk, couldn't even bring myself back. That B didn't just feel like a grade, it felt like my entire worth had been ripped out from under me. And here's the thing that B didn't make me second in my class. It tied me for first, but in my mind I had failed.

Speaker 0:

Fast forward a few years. It's Christmas Eve and I'm up until three in the morning wrapping gifts. Why? Because every crease in the paper had to be perfectly folded in. The paper had to be perfectly folded, every bow perfectly tied. If the wrapping paper looked perfect, maybe no one would notice how much of a mess I felt like inside.

Speaker 0:

And then came business. Oh boy, the first few years I would spend hours tweaking my website, adjusting fonts, shifting images by a single pixel, changing my offers again and again. And here's the truth I didn't want to admit. If I kept tweaking, it meant I didn't have to actually launch. And if I didn't launch, I couldn't get clients. And if I didn't get clients, I couldn't let anyone down. That wasn't high standards, that was fear.

Speaker 0:

It took me a long time to understand the difference between perfectionism and excellence. Perfectionism is about protecting yourself. As Brene Brown says, and I quote perfectionism is not the same thing as striving to be your best. Perfectionism is the belief that if we live perfect, look perfect and act perfect, we can minimize or avoid the pain of blame, judgment and shame. It's a shield. It's a 20-ton shield that we lug around thinking it will protect us, when in fact it's the thing that's really preventing us from flight. Excellence is about serving others. Perfectionism says don't show up until it's flawless. Excellence says show up fully, knowing you'll keep growing. Perfectionism keeps your gifts locked away. Excellence lets you share them, messy and alive, so they can make an impact now.

Speaker 0:

So I had to start intentionally doing things not perfect on purpose. I had to widen my window of tolerance for being seen when it wasn't all polished. I had to stop outsourcing my worth to gold stars, applause or client feedback. And I did a lot of inner work to get there Daily rituals, nervous system regulation, spiritual practices, reminders to myself over and over that I am enough Messy, imperfect, that I am enough Messy, imperfect, flawed, beautiful enough. Here's the truth. Perfectionism will keep you safe, but it will also keep you small.

Speaker 0:

The irony, the real magic happens when you let people see you before you feel ready. And this is exactly why the System Seer playbook is filled with both nervous system rituals and business systems. Because you can't out-strategize perfectionism. You have to regulate your body so it feels safe to show up. You have to have systems in place so your business runs, even when your brain says, wait, it's not ready yet. The playbook is the roadmap I wish I'd had back in those B-grade, bow-perfect, tweak-till-you-drop days. It's the exact process that took me from terrified of getting it wrong to creating from a place of ease, flow and self-trust. You can find all the details on my website Link is in the show notes or find me on Instagram. I'm the system seer. Just DM me the word playbook and I'll send you the link. So if perfectionism has been running your show, maybe it's time to try something different. Not perfect, not polished, just present. That's where the magic is. Have a beautiful day and I'll catch you on the next episode of Effortlessly Productive.

People on this episode

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

Overdrive Radio Artwork

Overdrive Radio

Kaine Legacy Studios
Your PUSH Coach Artwork

Your PUSH Coach

Josh Coats
The Modern Leadership Coaching Podcast Artwork

The Modern Leadership Coaching Podcast

Marc & Teresa Hildebrand
Organized Chaos Artwork

Organized Chaos

Teresa Hildebrand